Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Toby Green's avatar

Ok, so there’s now data on where parents to those born in the UK were born. But I don’t see how that data can lead one to conclude that ‘massive demographic change’ is underway in the UK or, indeed, that there’s change from past times. Why? Well, take my family as an example. My Scottish grandmother was born in NZ (c.1890) and her husband, my grandfather, equally Scottish, was born in Tibet (c.1885). My father, whose English parents met in France, was born in India in 1922 (which lead ChatGPT to reckon I’m Anglo-Indian). Why weren’t they born in the UK? Because of the globalisation of the day, aka the British Empire. In the dying days of the Empire, my parents met in Malta, and their children were born in the UK. Two of their four sons took advantage of modern-day globalisation and their (still British) children were born in France and Holland respectively, so of my parent’s nine grandchildren, five were born outside the UK. Two of the five live in the UK today. If you met any of us, you’d think us 100% British. I’m sure there are ten of thousands like us, some living in the UK today, some not. You probably have examples in your own family. Data on its own can’t tell the whole story.

Expand full comment
Christopher's avatar

Imagine how many more foreign births there will be if the child benefit cap is lifted ? Even more non working families straining the benefits system. ?

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts